top of page
Search

Grateful Dead listening notes and thoughts while working towards a book on "Dark Star" (VII)

17 hours ago
4 min read

Saturday 11/21/26

Trust the melody: the story of the 10/25/69 Winterland version of "Dark Star." They make it immediately plain they're going to be foregrounding and extemporizing the song's main theme. This isn't a mere theme--it's one of the finest melodies we have in music. Garcia even taps the Bright Star pattern about two-and-a-half minutes in, rather than at the piece's close. They know what a good thing they have. Improvisational veneration.


Increasingly I have these "I just can't" Dark Stars. What's an "I just can't" "Dark Star"? It's that point in the day when I say, "Enough of this world and the people of it, I can't anymore." Then I'll listen to a "Dark Star." A recent "I just can't" "Dark Star": the version at the Fillmore Auditorium on 12/20/69. One of two Christmas Dark Stars from that week, both of which very much feel like Christmas but for different reasons, which with this one has to do with the Bright Star peak. Like a Grateful Dead version of the 1945 short film, Star in the Night.


Sat down to check something regarding the "Dark Star" from 10/28/72 in Cleveland. But as so often happens, I remained there without intending to for the full half hour, transported by and held within the power of this art like no time at all had passed. The Beatles had a special relationship with time in their career, the Dead in the music of "Dark Star."


Two things the finest versions of "Dark Star" have in common: 1. The band's collective confidence is evident throughout. The music is extemporized--at least in large part--and yet it possesses a rare, almost beatific, but unwavering, surety. 2. There's a superabundance of energy, which is something that animates all great art. You can't have great art without it. But the Dead know exactly how to distribute this energy in these Dark Stars.


The Grateful Dead in spring 1969 were a sick (in the extreme positive manner) outfit. It's amazing music-making every night. You don't hear it mentioned, but the Modesto Junior College gig of 3/28 is a show that deserves a spot alongside the acknowledged heavies, a number of which it surpasses. The three April Boston shows are impeccable, surprising, bold, innovative, rife with both good humor and swagger. They remind me of Ricky Nelson's character in Rio Bravo; so good he can't help but prove it without trying to prove it.


11/13/72, Kansas City: two audience tapes, one made by Owsley Stanley which has more hum but is "rounder" and less metallic. The opening of "Dark Star" puts me in mind of the close of F. Scott Fitzgerald's "Basil and Cleopatra": "...Basil's heart went bobbing off around the ballroom in a pink silk dress..." One of those behold-this-beauty openings, like 5/15/70.


Those strafing lead lines of Jerry Garcia at the outset of the "Dark Star" at Vallejo's Dream Bowl on 2/22/69 before the slide into A with him kind of Ahmad Jamal-ing it, if you will, the elongated spaces between the notes suggesting the notes that aren't played. This was a major performance for them. A coming of age "Dark Star."


Offered a soundboard of the 11/8/70 Capitol Theatre show with the catch being I was required to part forever with the audience tape, I’d have to pass.


We're missing some of the evening's proceedings, but we have the electric portion of the performance at the Capitol Theatre on 11/5/70. You know they mean business by the defiant claim they stake to the opening "Hard to Handle." The early part of "Dark Star," meanwhile, borders on happy-go-lucky before dissolving into the Space section where it is in turn reassembled and sent back on its way from out the other side. You also get Feeling Groovy and Bright Star simultaneously.


Winterland 11/11/73: As Thanksgiving approached, the Dead gave a show to be thankful for. As I listen to it, I wonder if it's possible for any band to be less AI, if you will, than the Dead. Does musical art get more organic and human? Lest you're incredulous, I ask you to sit and listen to this "Dark Star" for its full half hour. Do nothing else. Put down the phone. Steady your hands. Close your eyes. Really listen--actively. You might find you're not the same afterwards.


11/15/69 and the Dead are playing a converted movie theater in Crockett, CA. Deep in the closing "Turn on Your Love Light" the power cuts out. McKernan attempts to handle the matter by having Weir speak/sing. We get ramshackle campfire harmonies. The night begins to dissolve. There are jungle yelps and drums. McKernan starts to blow crazy harmonica. Miraculously, the power returns. Garcia, saved and cued, goes off. The whole thing lasts forty-three minutes. It is thrilling.


The final three months of 1968 were when we started getting Dark Stars of the first order. Among them is the version played at the Silver Ground Fairgrounds in Chico, CA on 11/1. The sequence known as Bright Star generally speaking is among the most cathartic in music. Here, Garcia makes us wait with hints and feints, starts and stops, suggesting then pulling back, before choosing an ideal moment for its full expression.


A scalding autumn show: 10/22/67 at Winterland. Things were really coming together by now, the band stepping forward as something that hadn't existed before. They were leaving behind the psych-garage trappings so prevalent in 1966-67 rock. First version of "That's It for the Other One," no germination needed.


The nod to Bright Star around the ninety-second mark of the Grateful Dead's 4/14/72 Tivoli performance of "Dark Star." You had less idea than ever what would be coming when; they were so free and yet playing with such control.


11/19/72 in Houston: the only time the Dead finished a show with the "And We Bid You Goodnight" jam that typically preceded the return of "Not Fade Away." I love that: the gentle close, the putting down of instruments, and the leaving of the stage. "Thank you and goodnight," indeed.



 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page