Top 2000 baseball players of all-time, the Ovechkin albatross, most overrated player in Boston sports history, Shelby Foote and the Babe, Aaron on Clemente
Updated: 4 hours ago
Friday 11/20/26
The baseball history discussion forum I follow has been ranking the best players of all-time for quite a while now. I think they're like 240 rounds of voting deep. This is the same place that is currently undertaking a similar project to determine the top 100 position players in the game's history, which they last did in 2016.
What always strikes me about the first and larger project is how many fine ballplayers there have been. Guys who were really good are way down the list. For instance, I saw yesterday that Al Cowens, Leon Durham, and Eric Karros were right around the 2000th spot.
Cowens finished second in AL MVP voting in 1977. Do you know how many guys had big offensive years that season? Quite a few. Did he deserve to finish second? Well, probably not. I'd have had Carlton Fisk second behind Rod Carew. That's academic, though.
Eric Karros had five thirty home run/100 RBI seasons. Another year he went for 20 and 88, and in another 23 and 80. You have to be crazy good to be the 2000th best baseball player of all-time. Look at Leon Durham in 1984. He had a good run as a potent first baseman for the Cubs.
It isn't a big thing because who has anyone really played at this point of the season, but it's still nice to see BC men's basketball off to a 5-0 start with their new coach (and missing their best player the last couple games). In years past, they'd be 3-2 against the same competition.
If said new coach Luke Murray turns things around at BC--let's say they make the tournament in the next two or three years--that means he'll then leave for a better job and BC returns to, well, maybe not exactly where they were, but in a position where they could quickly be back exactly where they were. Within a season.
But I guess that's getting ahead of things. BC hasn't played anybody, as I suggested. BC also isn't an anybody themselves, to be fair, and it's been nearly twenty years since they started 5-0, which is why I mention it here. This is a team that has only had two winning seasons out of the last fifteen. A program that could previously hold its head high. They got into the Big Dance, made some noise there, won the Big East, could be a top twenty-five team. Then all that went away.
I'll see the conversations about weak out-of-conference schedules and how it doesn't get you ready for better in-conference competition. I think if you're not that good, or don't know you might be semi-decent, or you're trying to build, that it's a mistake to focus on playing better competition early. You'll lose, you won't build confidence, and that'll hurt you more when you get into conference play.
You want those wins and the burgeoning belief in yourself that comes with them. I think that's how you build when you're in a position like Boston College is now. Let's say they'd played better teams and were 2-3 but more "battle tested." Well, battle tested for what? You'd get into conference play having struggled, record-wise, probably lack belief, wouldn't be progressing as much having felt like you already hadn't progressed at all given the losses, and those losses would pile up swifter than they might have. I think BC is handling this, at least, the right way.
I also like the idea of socking away some wins early because you have a number like 20 victories in mind. You must win at least 20, pretty much, to start thinking/dreaming of the Big Dance. To insert yourself into the conversation of who goes. It's helpful to have things like this to play for. The longer you can utilize that motivation, the better, even if you don't get there. Then you build off that the next year. That's how program growth can happen.
Bruins got a needed win the other night against the Red Wings in Detroit. Those Wings are a mostly-reliable cure for what ails you, at least for one night. The Bruins have felt the absence of James Hagens, to be fair to him given my expressed thoughts in this journal as to the player he is and will be.
Hank Aaron said Roberto Clemente threw the ball like it had somewhere important to be. Gosh is that a neat way of putting it.
Through twenty games, Alexander Ovechkin has 1 goal and 5 assists. It has to be rough on a coach, the other players, and the fans, I suppose, though these types of things shouldn't impact your life much at all if you are a well person, when the entire operation is saddled with someone. The Caps could be punting away their year. Players have one less chance in their careers to win a Cup. You only have so many chances.
But what can you do now that the player has come back? An icon like this? There was a time when Ovechkin was the most dynamic player in the world. Didn't last long--like three years. Then he became this...people won't like this, but I think it's true...a Rob Deer type of player, to bring in someone from baseball. This one-dimensional guy who stood in a spot. Instead of swinging for the fences, Ovechkin one-timed for the back of the net.
He didn't skate anymore. Wasn't much playmaking. He stood and swung from the ass, if you will. Where is he on the all-time greats list? Is he in the top fifty? To the casual fan, he's top ten, because of the goals.
But that's a bit like Nolan Ryan and Pete Rose being the all-time bests for the person without a real clue about baseball and its history. Which is most people, including the people who watch baseball, post about baseball, write and talk about baseball professionally, and who do their creepy parasocial stuff with baseball.
BC product Ryan Leonard is leading that Caps team in scoring. Recent ex-BC guys are doing well in the league. I mentioned Hagens, though that's a small sample size and he's been out. Cutter Gauthier could pot 50 goals this year. I'm a little surprised by how good he's been in the NHL, but it doesn't look to be a fluke, given that he's doing this year what he did last year, and more so yet.
Connor McDavid's point streak was halted. What can you say? That Gretzky stuff is hard to do.
Two of the top five scorers in the league right now are defensemen.
Do you know who Rick Tocchet was? Okay, he's currently the coach of the Philadelphia Flyers, but what about Tocchet the player? He was a bruising, classic power forward right winger in the 1980s and 1990s. Scored goals, lots of PIMs. Threw those hands. Power forwards/fighters aren't playmakers, right? You know what Tocchet's season-high for assists was? 61.
Patrice Bergeron. First-ballot Hall of Famer. Center. Meant to facilitate and play-make. You know what Bergeron's season-high was for assists? 48. The most overrated player in the history of Boston sports. Has no business being in the Hall of Fame. And yet, there he is, first-ballot, because, why? Winning Selkes meant it was impossible for him to have a notable offensive game? Such was his mecessary devotion to playing defensively as a forward?
Is that what people think? Because I know that no one else thinks what I do about this player. Then again, what do people know? How deeply do they look? What can they discern from what they watch? I'll say this again, too: when Bergeron was in his prime, he wasn't the first line center on his own team. That was someone else who'll never be in the Hall of Fame. But sure, first-ballot Hall of Famer. And someone like Rick Middleton isn't in.
So much underachieving, too, over the course of Bergeron's Bruins' career, with him being a central figure and, I'd say, big reason why. He killed you the last time he played for the team after you won 65 regular-season games.
These days the late Shelby Foote usually catches hell for his Civil War history by people who've never read it, but I saw this video of an interview he gave that couldn't offend anyone. He described how when he was thirteen, his dad drove him and his nine-year-old cousin 150 miles to Memphis to see the Yankees play in an exhibition game there.
They parked behind the hotel, then went inside, asked what room Babe Ruth was in, and, this being a different time, as Foote says in the story, were provided with the information so they went up and knocked on the door.
Pretty cool, right? Foote said that the biggest man he'd ever seen opened the door to them. This was Lou Gehrig. I'm not surprised by Foote's reaction. I don't understand how Gehrig was that big. Look at the size of his arms, and, especially, his legs. These guys weren't lifting weights. How do you get muscles like that?
I guess what is somewhat surprising is that Gehrig was hanging out in Ruth's room. They weren't really buddies. Anyway, Gehrig turns and says to Ruth that he has visitors, and Ruth came to the door and was very gracious and shook everyone's hand.





Comments